Successive CGT rollovers can facilitate a business incorporation, merger or group restructure without an immediate capital gains tax liability. However, satisfying the technical requirements of each rollover does not necessarily resolve the tax treatment of the overall arrangement.
The ATO’s new draft PCG 2026/D5, Back-to-back CGT rollovers and Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 addresses when it will devote compliance resources to considering the general anti-avoidance provisions in connection with these arrangements. Its concern is particularly acute where an intermediate transaction has little commercial or practical utility beyond creating access to another rollover and an associated tax advantage.
The draft also provides an important opportunity to distinguish three questions that are sometimes conflated:
- Does each transaction satisfy the requirements of the relevant rollover?
- Does a connected transaction cause a “nothing else” condition to fail?
- Even if the rollovers are technically available, can Part IVA apply to the wider arrangement?
The Full Federal Court’s decision in AusNet Services Limited v Commissioner of Taxation 2025 FCAFC 21, the High Court’s subsequent refusal of special leave and TD 2020/6 inform different aspects of that analysis. They should not be treated as interchangeable authorities.
What are back-to-back CGT rollovers?
The draft addresses arrangements involving successive CGT events affecting the same asset, or its replacement asset, where rollover relief is chosen for successive events.
One example is transferring a business into a wholly owned company and then exchanging the shares in that company for shares in another company as part of a merger. The first rollover applies to the business assets; the second applies to the replacement shares.
There is no general prohibition on using rollovers in succession. The draft instead distinguishes arrangements presenting different levels of Part IVA compliance risk.
Its examples highlight the difference between transactions arising from independent commercial developments and a coordinated sequence in which an intermediate step facilitates a tax outcome unavailable through a more direct transaction.
That distinction emerges clearly from the draft’s examples.
Example 1: incorporation followed by an independently proposed merger
A sole trader transfers her business assets into a wholly owned company, claiming rollover relief under Subdivision 122-A.
An unrelated business owner subsequently approaches her with a merger proposal. The merger is implemented by exchanging her shares in the operating company for shares in the acquiring company, with scrip-for-scrip rollover relief under Subdivision 124-M.
The ATO treats its example as lower risk because the incorporation and subsequent merger arise from independent commercial decisions. The initial incorporation was not an intermediate step in a prearranged merger strategy.
This illustrates why the chronology of negotiations and decision-making matters. Two transactions can involve successive rollovers without forming a single, tax-driven sequence.
Nevertheless, lower compliance risk should not be confused with a binding determination that every statutory requirement has been satisfied or that Part IVA could never apply. The draft addresses the ATO’s compliance approach, not an automatic exemption from the legislation.
Example 2: an intermediate company used to facilitate a planned merger
Now consider a different starting point.
A business owner wants to transfer her sole trader business into an existing company owned with her sisters. In the circumstances of the ATO’s example, a direct transfer would trigger a capital gain and no rollover would be available.
Instead, the owner:
- Transfers the business to a new wholly owned company, using Subdivision 122-A.
- Exchanges the shares in that new company for shares in the existing family company, using Subdivision 124-M.
The ATO treats this example as higher risk because the intermediate company has no commercial or practical function beyond enabling the second rollover.
The intended business merger is not necessarily artificial. The concern is the route selected to achieve it.
That is a recurring feature of Part IVA analysis: a transaction can achieve a genuine commercial objective while the particular steps used to achieve it warrant separate examination. Conversely, the existence of a more heavily taxed alternative does not, by itself, establish a dominant tax-avoidance purpose.
Other tax outcomes attracting attention
The draft is not confined to the deferral of an immediate capital gain.
It also identifies concerns involving arrangements that produce:
- Successive rollovers may therefore require scrutiny where they interact with a subsequent group restructure or tax consolidation.
- Any resulting tax-cost uplift depends on the applicable statutory provisions and the facts. It is not an automatic consequence of either using successive rollovers or forming a consolidated group.
What does the ATO regard as problematic?
The draft’s central concern is the commercial or practical utility of the individual steps.
Relevant questions include:
- Why was an intermediate entity needed?
- What did the intermediate transaction achieve apart from access to another rollover?
- Were the transactions contemplated together
- Could the intended commercial outcome have been achieved more directly?
- What additional tax consequences arise from the chosen sequence?
Timing alone does not resolve those questions. The draft indicates that an interdependent arrangement can remain higher risk even where its implementation extends over a substantial period.
Equally, a short interval between transactions does not, without more, establish that Part IVA applies. The legal analysis requires consideration of the arrangement and its surrounding circumstances, rather than a mechanical timing rule.
The statutory-choice issue: what TR 2005/19 contributes
A natural response to the ATO’s concern is that Parliament expressly permits taxpayers to choose rollover relief.
That response is important, but not necessarily conclusive.
Section 177C(2) contains exclusions for certain tax benefits attributable to expressly provided agreements, elections or choices. Those exclusions are qualified where a scheme is entered into or carried out for the relevant purpose of creating the circumstances necessary to enable the choice to be made. The precise application depends on the relevant statutory paragraph and the benefit in question.
Making a choice is not the same as creating eligibility for it
In TR 2005/19, the ATO applies this distinction to scrip-for-scrip rollover arrangements. Its reasoning distinguishes between:
- Choosing rollover relief where the circumstances for that choice exist; and
- Implementing a scheme to create the circumstances in which the rollover choice becomes available.
That reasoning is directly relevant to an intermediate company introduced to facilitate a later share exchange. The ATO’s potential objection is not merely that the taxpayer chose a favourable tax treatment. It is that the arrangement created the eligibility conditions for obtaining that treatment.
TR 2005/19 is the Commissioner’s interpretation, not a judicial determination that Part IVA applies to the examples in the new PCG. Nevertheless, it shows that the underlying choice-versus-eligibility argument is not new.
Why this distinction does not settle the issue
Every rollover involves satisfying statutory conditions. Taxpayers commonly structure transactions with those conditions in mind.
It would therefore go too far to conclude that deliberately arranging a transaction to qualify for a rollover necessarily attracts Part IVA. The qualifications to the statutory-choice protection must be considered, and the substantive requirements of Part IVA must still be satisfied.
Losing the benefit of a choice exclusion is not, by itself, a finding of tax avoidance.
Where does AusNet fit?
In AusNet Services Limited v Commissioner of Taxation 2025 FCAFC 21, the Full Federal Court considered rollover treatment under Division 615 in connection with the restructure of a stapled group under a single holding company.
Unusually, the taxpayer sought to establish that the rollover did not apply. That position would have opened the way to higher tax values for underlying assets and larger depreciation deductions. The Commissioner successfully maintained that the rollover applied.
One issue concerned the requirement that shareholders receive shares in the interposed company “and nothing else”.
The taxpayer argued that shareholders received something more because the coordinated transactions increased the value of shares they already held. The majority rejected that argument, focusing on what shareholders received in exchange for disposing of their original interests, rather than every economic consequence of the restructure.
On 7 August 2025, the High Court refused special leave to appeal. That left the Full Federal Court’s decision standing. It was not a substantive High Court judgment endorsing every aspect of the reasoning, and it did not determine a Part IVA issue concerning back-to-back rollovers.
Does eligibility for a second rollover amount to “something else”?
AusNet supports caution about an expansive argument that every consequential economic or tax benefit constitutes additional consideration.
There is a distinction between:
- What a taxpayer receives in exchange for disposing of an asset or interest; and
- A tax consequence that follows from implementing the transaction.
The benefit of eligibility for another rollover should not simply be labelled additional consideration without analysing the language and operation of the particular provision.
However, AusNet did not specifically decide whether eligibility for a second rollover constitutes “something else”. Applying its reasoning to that question remains an exercise in statutory interpretation, not a direct application of a holding on identical facts.
What about TD 2020/6?
TD 2020/6 addresses what constitutes a “restructuring” for the purposes of subsection 125-70(1), within the demerger provisions.
Its principal proposition is not that the benefit of a second rollover necessarily constitutes additional consideration. Rather, the ATO seeks to identify the whole restructuring objectively, including connected transactions forming part of a wider plan.
Under the determination, transactions may form part of the same restructuring even if they are legally independent, contingent on different events or subject to separate decision-making processes. Temporal proximity is relevant, but not decisive.
That matters because paragraph 125-70(1)(c) requires the relevant owners to acquire new interests “and nothing else” under the restructuring.
For example, the determination distinguishes between:
- A sale of the head entity forming part of the same plan as the demerger; and
- A subsequent sale that does not form part of that restructuring.
Where the sale forms part of the restructuring, the ATO’s example concludes that the “nothing else” condition is not satisfied.
Does the new PCG change the ATO’s position?
The more precise description is that the PCG addresses a separate anti-avoidance question.
It is not principally an argument that eligibility for the second rollover is additional consideration that causes the first rollover to fail. Instead, it examines whether Part IVA warrants attention where successive rollovers operate technically but the overall sequence produces an additional tax advantage.
The draft should therefore not be described as withdrawing TD 2020/6 or conceding that the determination’s interpretation is incorrect.
Nor should it be presented as a direct response mandated by AusNet. The connection is analytical: the rollover eligibility inquiry and the Part IVA inquiry remain distinct.
Technical eligibility does not determine Part IVA
Part IVA does not apply merely because a taxpayer obtains a tax saving or selects a tax-effective transaction.
The analysis requires identification of a scheme, a relevant tax benefit and the requisite purpose, assessed objectively by reference to the statutory factors in section 177D. Those factors include the manner of implementation, form and substance, timing, tax results and changes in the financial positions of the taxpayer and connected persons.
Where the tax-benefit inquiry requires reconstruction of what might reasonably have happened without the scheme, the reasonableness of the alternative must be assessed under section 177CB. The commercial and economic substance of the actual arrangement is important to that exercise.
Accordingly, neither of these propositions is sufficient on its own:
- “Both rollovers satisfy their technical requirements, so Part IVA cannot apply.”
- “A direct transaction would have produced more tax, so Part IVA must apply.”
The statutory analysis must still be undertaken. The ATO’s higher-risk classification is an indication of likely compliance attention, not a substitute for that analysis.
Practical steps before implementing a restructure
For businesses and advisers contemplating successive rollovers, the draft provides a useful framework for transaction planning and file preparation.
1. Test each rollover independently
Identify the relevant taxpayer, asset, CGT event, consideration, ownership requirements and any necessary choices. Do not assume that satisfying one rollover establishes eligibility for the next.
2. Map the complete arrangement
Record all intended steps, including any planned merger, disposal, demerger or consolidation. Consider connected transactions rather than relying solely on the legal separation of individual documents.
3. Explain the role of each intermediate step
Document what an intermediate entity or transfer achieves commercially or practically. A general statement that the overall restructure serves a business purpose may not explain why the particular sequence was chosen.
4. Compare realistic alternatives
Identify the available commercial pathways and their material differences, including operational, financing, contractual and regulatory consequences—not merely their tax costs.
5. Consider the statutory-choice exclusions and their qualifications.
6. Identify any potential tax benefit and analyse Part IVA independently of rollover eligibility.
7. Preserve contemporaneous evidence
Keep board papers, correspondence, transaction proposals and records of negotiations showing when each step was first contemplated and why it was selected. Such evidence can help distinguish an independently arising transaction from a prearranged sequence.
These measures support, but do not replace, substantive advice on rollover eligibility and Part IVA. A well-documented arrangement can still attract Part IVA; documentation is valuable because it records the actual reasons and circumstances, not because it creates a commercial rationale after the event.
Current status and key takeaway
The ATO has a credible legal basis for examining a scheme that creates the circumstances necessary to access a rollover. TR 2005/19 explains its longstanding reasoning on that issue, while Part IVA can extend to intermediate steps within a genuine commercial restructure.
The limit is equally important: lack of independent commercial utility is evidence, not a substitute for the statutory analysis. A higher-risk classification does not establish liability, just as technical rollover eligibility does not exclude it.
PCG 2026/D5 remains a draft. Submissions close on 11 December 2026 and the draft proposes that the final guideline apply to arrangements entered into both before and after its issue date.
The central message is not that double rollovers are prohibited. It is that the tax analysis must address both the statutory operation of each rollover and the purpose and effect of the overall sequence.
AusNet is important to the interpretation of “nothing else”. TD 2020/6 remains relevant to identifying the scope of a demerger restructuring. The new PCG focuses on the separate risk that technically effective rollovers form part of an arrangement attracting Part IVA.
This article provides general information only and reflects the draft guidance available as at 13 November 2026. The tax consequences of a proposed restructure require advice on its particular facts.



